CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA (CVILLE RIGHT NOW) – Private-sector job growth in the Charlottesville region has nearly stalled since 2019, while government has supplied most of the area’s new jobs, according to the Fulton Mortgage Jobs Report released by the Free Enterprise Forum.
After the area saw robust private sector job growth from 2010-19, the survey finds 82% of new jobs in the area for government positions from 2019-25, according to the report.
After the area saw robust private-sector job growth from 2010-19, the survey finds that 82% of new jobs in the area from 2019-25 were government positions.
“When you look at what this community is, the government employment over the last six years or so has been overrepresented,” Neil Williamson, President and Executive Director of the Free Enterprise Forum said. “And I think the most recent activities of the economic development authorities have focused a great deal of energy, and we have some significant jobs on the horizon, but we have to realize we are incredibly reliant upon government jobs, including UVA.”
The report examines employment trends in seven localities: the City of Charlottesville and the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa, Nelson and Orange. It found 135,077 jobs in the region, 68% of them in the private sector.
It shows the Albemarle area, which previously outpaced the rest of Virginia in terms of job growth, is now trailing it.
“Private employment grew an average of 2.0% a year from 2010 to 2019 but just 0.1% a year since — the biggest slowdown of any metro area in Virginia,” according to a survey synopsis. “Private hiring has narrowed to education and health care; outside those industries, private employers have lost a combined total of nearly 2,000 jobs since 2019.”
Government, including the University of Virginia, accounted for 82% of the 3,832 jobs added in the region since 2019. Government is now the region’s largest employment sector, representing 31% of jobs and 35% of pay. Only four of 42 college metro areas have a larger public-sector share of workers.
One of the differences over the past six years, according to Williamson, “We’ve lost a lot of manufacturing jobs as employment fell, with American Woodmark in Orange County losing 139 jobs and Emerson in Albemarle losing 139 jobs.”
He noted we’ve lost jobs with three of our major private sector employers over the last six years while gaining jobs in four, which is a gain over that period of some 700 jobs.
The survey shows the expected losses around 2020 during the pandemic and a subsequent recovery of all those job numbers in 2023.
But since 2023, the survey shows private job growth essentially flat from that time forward and the flattest growth has been in Albemarle County and the City of Charlottesville.
Combined, those two localities added 128 private sector jobs from 2019-2025.
“Faster growth in Fluvanna, Greene and Louisa counties over the same period — about 1,300 jobs combined — was largely offset by losses in Nelson and Orange counties,” according to the report summary.
Charlottesville Economic Development Director Chris Engel told Cville Right Now he’s still digesting the report but said, “Charlottesville is one of several Virginia cities where private employment remains below 2019 levels.”
“Our decline was greater than some and smaller than others. As the report notes, some jobs previously reported in the city are now counted in Albemarle County, contributing to the city’s decline and the county’s gain,” he said. “Remote and hybrid work further complicate where jobs are reported and how we interpret those changes.”
He said there has been recovery since 2019 overall in the region with slower private sector job creation as that recovery has indeed been uneven.
“Economies function across city and county lines, so it is important to consider that broader picture alongside individual locality figures,” he said. “The increasing concentration of employment in government (largely associated with UVA) and the slowdown in private-sector growth deserve our attention.”
He said these findings reinforce the importance of working together as a region to support existing businesses, encourage new investment, and create more private sector opportunities.
“Particularly jobs that offer middle-income wages and pathways for advancement,” he said.
New jobs on the horizon can help broaden the scope, Williamson said, if AstraZeneca, Afton Scientific, and L3Harris all deliver on their announcements.
“They would be generating… about 1,155 new jobs which is enough to raise regional manufacturing by close to one-fifth,” he said. “And if all of the data centers that are currently on the books and approved in Louisa come through, that would just add more information jobs.”
“Although there are different benchmarks for how many jobs once they’re built that each data center will actually produce,” said Williamson.
Albemarle County Economic Development Director Emily Kilroy said to Cville Right Now about the three new companies the report mentions, “We’re really just getting started.”
“Our region is really taking a fresh look at how do we work together, how do we work differently than we have in the past, in order to best position of the localities in our region to be successful in economic development projects,” Kilroy said. “Economic development is a really strong answer and a way to increase revenues without having to increase the tax rate on the residential homeowner in our community.”
“Our ability to generate employment opportunities and investments by private companies in our community is another way for us to continue to provide good services and enhance some of those services into our future,” said Kilroy.
Kilroy said she’s grateful to Fulton Mortgage and the Free Enterprise Forum for “digging into the data,” because there’s a lot of value to having another party issue such a report with a different set of eyes.
She noted there will always be a large percentage of government jobs in our area.
“Many people know we have a federal installation in Albemarle County with a large number of federal employees as does Shenandoah National Park and some other small agencies that are here,” she said. “Not everyone realizes that University of Virginia jobs are classified as state government jobs, and a lot of people don’t realize how many jobs are created by local government which include the public school systems.”
Because of that, she doesn’t see the flat private-sector growth coming out of the pandemic as very bad news.
“During the pandemic, government didn’t lose jobs like a lot of private sector industries experienced, and so we didn’t lose as many jobs in our area because of how many government jobs we have,” said Kilroy. “So, we didn’t recover as strongly and create new jobs as robustly in our region coming out of the pandemic because we didn’t lose as many jobs.”
She classified that as “to be expected” when looking at the area’s jobs mix.